An Analysis of the Formalisation Policies Regarding Street Vending

Document Type : Research Paper

Author

Assistant Professor, Faculty of Urban Planning, University of Tehran

Abstract

Policies on street vending can play a significant role in inclusive urban governance via securing the livelihoods of the urban poor and hence reducing poverty, and by considerably reducing the budget that is annually spent on managing or relocating street vendors,. Therefore, this paper analyses the formalisation policies of street vending, which have been a dominant discourse among national and city authorities during the past five years in the country. This paper studies two types of suggested programs, which are in line with formalization policies: 1. Licensing street vendors; 2. Relocating street vendors to formal commerce centres. This study employs WPA as its analytical framework for policy analysis and adopts content and discourse analysis, using Atlas.ti as its methods of data analysis. This study also looks into similar policies and programmes and their impacts in twenty one countries in the global south. The results show that by overlooking the interwoven relationship between ‘formal policies’ and ‘informal policies’, the formalization of policies often fail to achieve their objectives. In particular, these policies and programmes fail to target and assist the most vulnerable groups. Furthermore, they fail to plan or take into consideration numerous street vendors, who do not benefit from these programmes and have no other way in which to earn their livelihoods. As a result, with most vendors coming back to urban spaces, these policies and programmes are likely to waste the country’s budget and make street vendors even more vulnerable than before.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

1. ثقفی، مراد (۱۳۹۴). «دستفروشان بساط‌گستر در شهر تهران: واقعیت‌های آماری، راهکارهای انسانی»، میدان، برگرفته از لینک .http://medn.me/k4qjt
2. خبرگزاری خانه ملت (1397). برگرفته از سایت: https://www.icana.ir/Fa/News/418815/.
3. سازمان اسناد و کتابخانه ملی ایران.
4. مرکز پژوهش‌های مجلس (۱۳۹۸). «گزارش نظارتی ماده (16) با عنوان سیاستگذاری هوشمندانه شهرداری‌ها برای فروشندگان کم‌سرمایه و دستفروشان»، دفتر اقتصادی، شماره مسلسل 16409.
5. Adama, O. (2020). "Abuja is not for the Poor: Street Vending and the Politics of Public Space", Geoforum, 109.
6. Alva, R. J. (2014). "The Street Vendors (Protection of Livelihood and Regulation of Street Vending) Bill, 2013, Is the Cure Worse Than the Disease?", Statute Law Review, 35(2).
7. Anjaria, J. S. (2011). "Ordinary States: Everyday Corruption and the Politics of Space in Mumbai", American Ethnologist, 38(1).
8. Bayat, A. (2013). Life as Politics: How Ordinary People Change the Middle East, Stanford University Press.
9. Bell, J. S. and A. Loukaitou-Sideris (2014). "Sidewalk Informality: An Examination of Street Vending Regulation in China", International Planning Studies, 19(3-4).
10. Boonjubun, C. (2017). "Conflicts Over Streets: The Eviction of Bangkok Street Vendors", Cities, 70.
11. Chen, M. A., S. Roever and C. Skinner (2016). "Urban Livelihoods: Reviewing the Evidence in Support of the New Urban Agenda", The New Urban Agenda.
12. Crossa, V. (2016). "Reading for Difference on the Street: De-homogenising Street Vending in Mexico City", Urban Studies, 53(2).
13. De Soto, H. (2000). The Mystery of Capital: Why Capitalism Triumphs in the West and Fails Everywhere Else, Civitas Books.
14. Donovan, M. G. (2008). "Informal Cities and the Contestation of Public Space: The Case of Bogotá's Street Vendors, 1988-2003", Urban Studies, 45(1).
15. Fadaee, S. and S. Schindler (2017). "Women Hawkers in Tehran’s Metro: Everyday Politics and the Production of Public Space", International Development Planning Review, 39(1) .
16. Falla, A. M. V. and S. C. Valencia (2019). "Beyond State Regulation of Informality: Understanding Access to Public Space By Street Vendors in Bogotá", International Development Planning Review, 41(1).
17. Ferragut, S and G. M. Gómez (2013). "From The Street to the Store: the Formalization of Street Vendors in Quito, Ecuador", Securing Livelihoods: Informal Economy Practices and Institutions, 214 .
18. Goodwin, S. (2011). "Analysing Policy as Discourse: Methodological Advances in Policy Analysis", In L. Markauskaite, P. Freebodyand J. Irwin (Eds.), Methodological Choice and Design, Scholarship, Policy and Practice in Social and Educational Research, New York, Springer.
19. Hanser, A. (2016)."Street Politics: Street Vendors and Urban Governance in China", The China Quarterly, 226.
20. Huang, G., D . Xue and Z. Li (2014). "From Revanchism to Ambivalence: The Changing Politics of Street Vending in Guangzhou", Antipode, 46(1).
21. Hunt, S. (2009). "Citizenship's Place: The State's Creation of Public Space and Street Vendors' Culture of Informality in Bogota, Colombia", Environment and Planning D: Society and Space, 27(2).
22. Iguida, E. O. (2019). "Exploring the Theories, Determinants and Policy Options of Street Vending: A Demand-Side Approach", Urban Studies, 57(1).
23. Keshavarzian, A. (2009). "Regime Loyalty and Bāzārī Representation Under the Islamic Republic of Iran: Dilemmas of the Society of Islamic Coalition", International Journal of Middle East Studies, 41(2).
24. Kudva, N. (2009). "The Everyday and the Episodic: the Spatial and Political Impacts of Urban Informality", Environment and Planning. A, 41(7) .
25. Linares Lissette, A. (2018). "The Paradoxes of Informalizing Street Trade in the Latin American city", International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 38(7-8).
26. Lindell, I. (2019). "Introduction: Re-Spatialising Urban Informality: Reconsidering the Spatial Politics of Street Work in The Global South", International Development Planning Review, 41(1).
27. Lyons, M., A. Brown and C. Msoka (2014). "Do Micro Enterprises Benefit From the ‘Doing Business’ Reforms? The Case of Street-vending in Tanzania", Urban Studies, 51(8).
28. Maneepong, C and J. C. Walsh (2013). "A New Generation of Bangkok Street Vendors: Economic Crisis as Opportunity and Threat", Cities, 34.
29. Martínez, L., R. Short and D. Estrada (2017). "The Urban Informal Economy: Street Vendors in Cali, Colombia", Cities, 66.
30. Mcfarlane, C. (2012). "Rethinking Informality: Politics, Crisisand the City", Planning Theory and Practice, 13(1).
31. Meneses-Reyes, R. (2018). "(Un) Authorized: A Study on the Regulation of Street Vending in Latin America", Law and Policy, 40(3).
32. Ojeda, L. and A. Pino (2019). "Spatiality of Street Vendors and Sociospatial Disputes Over Public Space: The Case of Valparaíso, Chile", Cities, 95.
33. Onodugo, V. A., N. H. Ezeadichie, C. A. Onwuneme and A. E. Anosike (2016). "The Dilemma of Managing the Challenges of Street Vending in Public Spaces: The Case of Enugu City, Nigeria", Cities, 59.
34. Öz, Ö and M. Eder (2012). "Rendering Istanbul's Periodic Bazaars Invisible: Reflections on Urban Transformation and Contested Space", International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 36(2).
35. Palacios, R. (2016). "The New Identities of Street Vendors in Santiago, Chile", Space and Culture, 19(4).
36. Recio, R. B. and J. E. A. Gomez (2013). "Street Vendors, Their Contested Spacesand the Policy Environment: A View from Caloócan, Metro Manila", Environment and Urbanization ASIA, 4(1).
37. Recio, R. B., I. Mateo-Babiano and S. Roitman (2017). "Revisiting Policy Epistemologies on Urban Informality: Towards a Post-dualist View", Cities, 61.
38. Roever, S. (2016). "Informal Trade Meets Informal Governance: Street Vendors and Legal Reform in India, South Africaand Peru", Cityscape, 18(1).
39. Roever, S. and C. Skinner (2016). "Street Vendors and Cities", Environment and Urbanization, 28(2).
30. Roy, A. (2005). "Urban Informality: Toward an Epistemology of Planning", Journal of the American Planning Association, 71(2).
31. --- (2009). "Why India Can not Plan its Cities: Informality, Insurgence and the Idiom of Urbanization", Planning Theory, 8(1).
32. --- (2016). "Informality and the Politics of Planning", In J. Hillier and P. Healey (Eds.), The Ashgate Research Companion to Planning Theory (pp. 105-126): Routledge.
33. Schindler, S. (2014). "Producing and Contesting the Formal/Informal Divide: Regulating Street Hawking in Delhi, India", Urban Studies, 51(12).
34. Steel, G. (2012). "Whose Paradise? Itinerant Street Vendors' Individual and Collective Practices of Political Agency in the Tourist Streets of Cusco, Peru", International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 36(5).
35. Taylor, J. and L. Song (2016). "Return to the Streets", Cityscape, 18(1).
36. Te Lintelo, D. J. H. (2017). "Enrolling a Goddess for Delhi’s Street Vendors: The Micro-politics of Policy Implementation Shaping Urban (in) formality", Geoforum, 84.
37. Tucker, J. (2017). "City-stories: Narrative as Diagnostic and Strategic Resource in Ciudad Del Este, Paraguay", Planning Theory, 16(1).
38. Tucker, J. and R. T. Devlin (2019). "Uncertainty and the Governance of Street Vending: A Critical Comparison Across the North/South Divide", International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 43(3).
39. Weng, C. Y and A. M. Kim (2016). "The Critical Role of Street Vendor Organizations in Relocating Street Vendors in to Public Markets: The Case of Hsinchu City, Taiwan", Cityscape, 18(1).
40. Xue, D. and G. Huang (2015). "Informality and the State’s Ambivalence in the Regulation of Street Vending in Transforming Guangzhou, China", Geoforum, 62.
 

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics